Page
1
(This page has no text content)
Page
2
(This page has no text content)
Page
4
(This page has no text content)
Page
5
CODING DEMOCRACY HOW HACKERS ARE DISRUPTING POWER, SURVEILLANCE, AND AUTHORITARIANISM MAUREEN WEBB FOREWORD BY CORY DOCTOROW THE MIT PRESS CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS LONDON, ENGLAND
Page
6
© 2020 Maureen Webb All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by any electronic or mechanical means (including photocopying, recording, or information storage and retrieval) without permission in writing from the publisher. This book was set in ITC Stone and Avenir by Toppan Best-set Premedia Limited. Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Data Names: Webb, Maureen, author. | Doctorow, Cory, writer of foreword. Title: Coding democracy : how hackers are disrupting power, surveillance, and authoritarianism / Maureen Webb. Description: Cambridge, MA : MIT Press, [2020] | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2019018826 | ISBN 9780262043557 (hardcover : alk. paper) Subjects: LCSH: Hacktivism. | Cyberspace- - Political aspects. | Internet- - Social aspects. | Hacktivism. | Computer security. | Internet- - Social aspects. | Democratization. Classification: LCC HV6773 .W427 2020 | DDC 364.16/8- - dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2019018826 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Page
7
To those in precarious situations
Page
8
(This page has no text content)
Page
9
CONTENTS FOREWORD BY CORY DOCTOROW xi AUTHOR’S NOTE xv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS xix 1 THE HACKER ETHIC: GERMANY’S CHAOS COMPUTER CLUB AND THE GENEALOGY OF THE HACKER ETHOS 1 In Berlin 1 Getting to the Chaos Commmunication Camp 2 First- Wave Hackers: Hacking Culture in the US from the Late 1950s, including the Hands- On Imperative and Other Principles of a Hacker Ethos 5 Second- Wave Hackers: Computers and Code for the People, including the People’s Computer Company, The WELL, Homebrew, Silicon Valley, RMS, and Free Software 10 First- Wave Europe: The Early Development of European Hacker Culture in the 1970s and 1980s 13 The Early Days of the Chaos Computer Club 15 1989: A Watershed Year for Germany and the CCC 18 The Fall of the Wall 21 The 1990s: Hackerdom Expands, Silicon Valley Takes Off, and a Schism Develops between the Philosophies of Proprietary Software and Free Software 22 First Impressions: Be Excellent to Each Other 29
Page
10
viii Contents 2 THE HACKER CHALLENGE: CYPHERPUNKS ON THE ELECTRONIC FRONTIER 33 Third- Wave Hackers: The Cypherpunks 33 Fellow Travelers, Reluctant Heroes, and the Cryptowars of the 1990s 40 The Smart- Ass Antipodean 51 3 A MANIFESTO FOR THE TWENTY- FIRST CENTURY: PRIVACY FOR THE WEAK, TRANSPARENCY FOR THE POWERFUL 53 Code Is Law, and the Onion Router Proves It 53 WikiLeaks 56 A New Kind of Cypherpunk 60 Snowden 65 A Manifesto for the Twenty- first Century and the Concept of Popular Sovereignty 68 4 THE BURDEN OF SECURITY: THE CHALLENGES FOR THE ORDINARY USER 71 Security 101 71 The Sakharovs 78 Berlin: City of Freedom, City of Exiles 79 A Cryptoparty 84 5 DEMOCRACY IN CYBERSPACE: FIRST, THE GOVERNANCE PROBLEMS 93 Harry 93 Internet Governance: “Loraxes Who Speak for the Trees” 95 Harry Redux 98 Of Trees and Tongues 101 What Is Democracy? Or How to Govern Democratically in a World That Is No Longer Flat? 105 Hacker Governance: Noisy Square 108 6 CULTURE CLASH: HERMES AND THE ITALIAN HACKINGTEAM 111 The Italian Embassy 111 Black, White, and Gray 114 7 DEMOCRACY IN CYBERSPACE: THEN THE DESIGN PROBLEMS 125 The Problem of Provable Security 125 The Problem of Designing Privacy- Preserving Protocols 127 Email: A Case in Point 130 Remaking the Internet for the Twenty- first Century 135
Page
11
Contents ix 8 THE GATHERING STORM: THE NEW CRYPTO— AND INFORMATION AND NET NEUTRALITY AND FREE SOFTWARE AND TRUST- BUSTING— WARS 139 A New Digital Era Civics Is Necessary 139 The New Cryptowars 140 The New Information Wars 145 The New Net Neutrality Wars 153 The New Free Software Wars 157 The New Trust- Busting Wars and the Unsustainability of Current Digital Capitalism 164 The Gathering Storm 172 9 HACKER OCCUPY: BRINGING OCCUPY INTO CYBERSPACE AND THE DIGITAL ERA 175 The Occupy Movement 175 A Multitude of Diverse Experiments 185 Hacking Experiments Using Federated Technology, or the Basic Internet Structure 186 Hacking Experiments Using P2P Distributed Technology 191 Hacking Experiments Using the Blockchain 194 Solid? 198 The Blockchain Reality Check 202 “The Next System” 204 10 DISTRIBUTED DEMOCRACY: EXPERIMENTS IN SPAIN, ITALY, AND CANADA 207 Getting Control of Democratic Processes: The Indignant of Barcelona 207 Hacking Corruption: Xnet’s 15MpaRato 211 Hazte Banquero (Become a Banker) 217 Maddish: Platforms for the People 220 PartidoX 222 Homage to Catalonia 230 Hacking Electoral Politics in Italy: “A New Politics Is Possible” 233 Hacking Democratic Decision Making Itself: A Canadian Algorithm for Global Democracy 243 No More Wrecking Balls 247 11 THE VALUE AND RISK OF TRANSGRESSIVE ACTS: CORRECTIVE FEEDBACK 249 Berlin’s Graffiti 249 The Value of Transgressive Acts 252 The Risk of Transgressive Acts 255 Hacker Crackdown 3.0 259 Where Power Meets Its Limits: The Making of Martyrs 271 Democratic Constitutionalism as Conversation Leading to Rough Consensus 275
Page
12
x Contents 12 MAINSTREAMING HACKERDOM: A NEW CONDITION OF FREEDOM 281 A City upon a Hill 281 Libre Planet, the Heart of Free Software 284 Richard Stallman and the Free Software Foundation Awards 290 Pros, Cons, and Disobedience Awards 292 MIT’s Media Lab 297 Harvard and the Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society 303 Emergence 307 Enlivening a Moral Imagination 309 The Epicenter of a Civilization 318 CODA 321 NOTES 323 INDEX 369
Page
13
FOREWORD: THERE ARE TWO KINDS OF PEOPLE Cory Doctorow When you’re small, you’re taught that there are two kinds of people: 1. good ones, and 2. bad ones. As you get older, if you’re lucky enough to have the right kinds of teach- ers and the right opportunities for learning, you realize that there are indeed two kinds of people: 1. people who think there are two kinds of people (“good ones” and “bad ones”), and 2. people who think that people are pretty much a mixed bag, prone to venality and capable of nobility, fallible and self- deceiving; and that the goodness or badness of a person from moment to moment has more to do with the structures we build to act as a check on fallibility than it does with the intrinsic virtues or wickedness of any one of us. The name for the systems we build to elevate virtue and check vice is “politics,” and, practiced correctly, it can produce a sum that is greater than the whole of its parts: a superhuman machine capable of superhu- man feats. Literally: welding together more than one person to accom- plish a common end enables outcomes that are more than one person could ever hope for. Superhuman.
Page
14
xii FoReWoRD For a quarter- century, dreamers, theorists, schemers, builders, opti- mists, pessimists, crackpots, and geniuses have run a series of experi- ments in connecting people using networked computers, experimenting with governance structures (ICANN, github, Unix file permissions, stan- dards development organizations, Reddit upvotes, statutes, treaties, regu- lations), normative frameworks (manifesti, terms of service, moderator guidelines), tools (encryption, error correction, ranking algorithms), and businesses (eBay, Amazon, iTunes, Google Play, the Silk Road), trying to find ways to upregulate desirable behaviors and downregulate the bad ones. The societal view of this project has been a mess: at first, it was widely dismissed as a distraction, a toy for nerds who believed that somehow their Star Trek message- boards had some political consequence. Then, in a hot second, the outside world pivoted to mock tech activists for their supposed “techno- optimism” and alleged indifference to the ways in which tech had become a dominant political force in the world. These two points of view— tech doesn’t matter versus tech matters too much to listen to nerds— have one thing in common: they’re both most commonly evinced by people who don’t understand tech very well. This is a book that aims to bridge that divide in understanding, and at this political moment that’s an important contribution. I don’t mean that critics lack an appreciation of how tech businesses work (although many do), or of the human frailties of technologists themselves (these are often self- evident): I mean that, at a nuts- and- bolts level, they tend not to understand what’s going on when they sit in front of a computer and make it do things, or have things done to them. When better- informed activists point out the technical incoherence of some critiques (e.g. “Why can’t YouTube just use an algorithm to block hate speech?”), they are accused of a mulish intransigence dressed up as tech- nical objections. All too often, the answer to “that’s just not possible,” is “NERD HARDER!” The thing is, technology activists are, in fact, enthusiastic about tech- nology. They really do believe that with technology, we can create struc- tures that upregulate the angels of our better nature and downregulate the venal, cowardly, and unworthy impulses. If that was all that tech activists believed, then it would be totally fair to call them monsters of
Page
15
FoReWoRD xiii hubris, the unwitting handmaidens of technological oppression through ubiquitous surveillance and control. But that’s not all tech activists believe. They believe that everything could be so great but only if we don’t screw it up. After all, if you’re an infor- mation security person, your whole job is to sit around and think of how terrible people will abuse the systems you’re charged with protecting. If you’re an information security specialist, you have to both love and fear tech — the way that a demolitions expert loves and fears dynamite. The hacker way has its problems: “move fast and break things” was always self- serving bullshit fronted by overgrown toddlers who wanted to grift their way to millions (billions!) without adult supervision. But the way hackers do policy— deploying deep, hard- won technical expertise to build and modify systems with some real concern for sys- tems’ societal effects and an approach that reduces how much agreement we need before we can work together— is admirable. It is animated by a profound understanding of the perils of tech gone wrong as much as by an exuberance at the transformative power of tech. This is a book about hackers and hacker politics: the nuts- and- bolts and the big picture. The people who appear in it (including, briefly, me) are, like our fellow human beings— deeply flawed, cracked vessels who struggle to contain bad impulses and to let the pure water of our noble ones pour out freely. Hacker politics are anti- authoritarian because hackers know that authorities are just as damaged as they are. Hacker politics are pluralis- tic because hackers know that unchecked power is a catastrophe in the making, because without those checks, the bugs in the system will run wild and brick the device before you even know there’s something wrong there. It is a political ethos that accounts for the fallibility of human beings as much as for their unlimited potential. It is designed to avoid making things worse, even if doesn’t always know how to make them better. Hacker politics may not solve our problems, but as this book makes clear, they are going to be part of the solution.
Page
16
(This page has no text content)
Page
17
AUTHOR’S NOTE As this book was well into production, in August 2019, a series of allega- tions began to emerge against a number of people and institutions fea- tured in the text. These allegations linked sex offender Jeffrey Epstein to MIT and to Harvard, and also to faculty and donors at those institutions, including MIT Media Lab Director Joi Ito and MIT professor Marvin Min- sky (now deceased). In early September, The New Yorker reported that Ito had accepted numerous donations to the Media Lab from Epstein after the latter’s conviction in 2008 for soliciting prostitution from a minor, as well as more than $1 million for Ito’s own personal investments. It alleged that Ito had concealed the donations. Around the same time, the President of MIT, Rafael Reif, admitted that he had approved a donation from Epstein to a University faculty member in 2012 and had signed a thank- you note to him. Marvin Minsky, meanwhile, was accused of sexu- ally exploiting a 17- year- old female (more than 55 years his junior) alleg- edly trafficked by Epstein. LinkedIn cofounder and MIT Media Lab donor Reid Hoffman defended Ito, and Free Software Foundation founder and MIT research scientist Richard Stallman defended Minsky in ways that drew immediate pub- lic condemnation and disgust. In September, Ito resigned as Director of the Media Lab, and Richard Stallman resigned from his positions at the Free Software Foundation and MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial
Page
18
xvi AuthoR’s note Intelligence Lab (CSAIL). The allegations against Ito and the Media Lab led to the departures of associate professor Ethan Zuckerman and visit- ing scholar J. Nathan Matias from the Lab, who stated that they could no longer be associated with the institution. Ito’s failure to respond, and Hoffman’s defensive response when questioned by Anand Giridharadas, led to the resignation of that journalist and author from the board over- seeing the Media Lab Disobedience Award. I first started reading about these stories huddled in a tent at the 2019 Chaos Communication Camp, the freezing black night illuminated only by the light of the news articles displayed on my cell phone. It was a lot to take in over the high- decibel punk music and partying that were shak- ing the ground outside. Dismay was my initial emotion. My book reports, among many other things, on these individuals’ contributions to the history of hacking. What was the proper course of action? Even if I could have excised pas- sages about the impugned individuals entirely from the book at that late stage of the production process, I would not have done it. I don’t believe it’s fair or wise to erase people and their accomplishments from history in order to serve one’s own professional interests. We miss the opportu- nity to process difficult lessons when we self- righteously rush to scrub someone from the face of an institution, a movement, a profession, or the public record. And as a lawyer I believe that each individual’s case must be examined and judged on its own set of facts in the appropriate forums. Everyone is entitled to due process. Granted, each individual may be judged, too, in the forum of public opinion. But when we make our own judgments we need to think, not just about individual culpability but about the systems in which indi- viduals are embedded, too. For me, these stories underline the overwhelming gender imbalance in the computing and high- tech worlds. It’s an imbalance that poses real challenges for holistic tech solutions for our societies. The stories show the danger of universities being corrupted by private and corporate money, and losing sight of their public mandates. They show privileged elites making terrible decisions. By their depressing mulitiplicity, the sto- ries suggest a general moral crisis. In my view the takeaway is clear: we need to rebuild our societies and institutions with a new ethos of distributed power. It is our collective responsibility. That is what this book is about.
Page
19
AuthoR’s note xvii At this time, too, it is important to mention that Julian Assange is in prison in the United Kingdom, having been turned out of his sanctuary at the Ecuadorian Embassy in London and forcibly extracted from the building by police. Sweden’s investigation against him for sexual crimes has been dropped, reopened by prosecutors, and recently put on hold by a Swedish court, but he is now serving prison time in the United King- dom for skipping bail (in 2012) and might be extradited to the United States. There is heavy disapprobation of him in the hacker scene. I expe- rienced this firsthand at the recent Chaos Communication Camp in 2019. However, regardless of what one thinks of each of Assange’s many actions, his personality, his mental state, his motivations, and his treat- ment of other people, especially women, over the years, it is important to recognize that his case is, above all, a case about press freedom. What the UK and US governments decide to do with him will set the course for press freedom in this century. In that respect we should all be speaking up and getting involved in the matter because as this book describes, we won’t be living in democracies if we don’t have a free press. I imagine many more developments will unfold before and after the publication of this book to highlight the pressing relevance of its subject matter. My one hope is that you will feel that you understand what’s going on better once you’ve read it. That is the public service I have aimed to provide. In solidarity, Maureen Webb Fall 2019 Vancouver
Page
20
(This page has no text content)